Member's Hunt: Playing the Odds

by
posted on September 3, 2018
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
mh-playingtheodds_lead.jpg

By Ruben Conde Jr., Wellton, Ariz.

It was mid-November and I’d been planning our 2017 Arizona muzzleloader elk hunt since May. My wife had been sick for more than a week, and now it was looking like she wouldn’t make it on the trip.

“You two all packed up and ready to go?” my dad asked over the phone.

“I am,” I said. “But Wendy’s still sick.”

“Oh,” he replied. “So, you’re going alone? Have a good trip.”

Thirty minutes later, my phone rang again.

“Hey, I’d like to go with you if you don’t mind,” my dad stated. I was relieved! I anticipated he’d be a big help, since he has been hunting elk since the 1970s.

November rolled around, and on opening day, the thermometer read minus 1. I’d taken five bulls from this unit since 2005, four of them with a muzzleloader. We always found elk sign. I don’t mind spending a few days “ground truthing” the sign myself. I’m old school that way.

“Have any rain gear?” my dad asked as we were waiting for it to get light enough to start into the woods.

“Yeah,” I said, pointing at the Ranger.

“Taking it with you?” he inquired.

“No, why? It’s not going to rain,” I replied. I checked the forecast. No rain was going to be here for a week. My dad isn’t into weather apps and such. He takes a look at the sky and makes an educated guess. That’s his old-school quirk.

Around 7:30 a.m., an elk quartered toward me about 100 yards out, and that’s when a small 4x4 stepped into the clearing I was standing in! I stood frozen as he stopped and realized I was something. After several seconds, the bull continued on. Then a second elk, a spike, stepped out. He stopped at 50 yards and stared at me a few moments. Satisfied in his assumption that I was harmless, he, too, went on his way.

At 8:30 it started raining. The rest of the morning, I was forced to hunt from one juniper tree to the next, trying to keep my powder dry. Note to self: Dad apparently has better instincts than my weather app!

About 2:30 p.m., the rains finally let up, and I didn’t hear a word along the lines of, “I told you so …” from my dad.

The next day only turned up 11 coyotes. After I met up with Dad once more, he told me he glassed up a large bull on a nearby knoll. We drove to a good vantage point and continued to glass, but to no avail.

On the third day of the hunt, I was on a mountain overlooking a small canyon. It was dark and full of beds. I slowly worked down to the canyon’s edge and back while I looked under each tree for telltale signs of an ear flicking or sunlight glinting off an antler tine. My third trip to the edge of the canyon proved fruitful. There he was, barely 60 yards below me, facing down the canyon. I raised my .50-caliber Remington 700ML, aimed a few inches forward on his left shoulder and squeezed.

Through the white cloud of smoke, I saw the bull bolt forward. He looked back toward me and then toppled over. Now I had time to get the shakes. As I looked down this little canyon, I realized how rugged it was, narrow and paved with boulders. I worked my way down to the bull and found he was a fine 6x7.

“I’ve got a bull down!” I exclaimed over the radio to my dad. It was 1:30 p.m.

As I watched my dad hike up the canyon, I realized this 79-year-old man was tough, but I couldn’t see him helping pack this bull out. It was going to be a long day!

By 5 p.m. we had quartered and boned out the bull, and hung the pieces in a giant oak. My dad helped where and when he could, but he mostly offered moral support.

“You know I’m not going to be able to help you pack any of this out, right?” he asked.

“I know,” I said.

It took seven trips out of the small canyon to pack out all the pieces. Loading the last piece in the Ranger, my dad looked at me.

“I can’t believe you packed all that out,” he said. “You’re the man!” I couldn’t remember ever getting a compliment like that from him in my 52 years.

“So how many does this make for you?” my dad asked on the drive home.

“Six for six,” I said proudly.

“How about me?” he asked.

“Three for four,” I said.

“Oh, thought it was more,” he replied.

There’s always next year, I thought to myself. Hopefully, I’ll go seven for seven.

Do you have an exciting, unusual or humorous hunting experience to share? 
Send your story (800 words or less) to [email protected] or to American Hunter, Dept. MH, 11250 Waples Mill Road, Fairfax, VA. 22030-9400. Please include your NRA ID number. Good quality photos are welcome. Make sure you have permission to use the material. Authors will not be paid, and manuscripts and photos will not be returned. All material becomes the property of NRA.

Latest

375 Family Lead Photo
375 Family Lead Photo

Cartridge Legacies: The .375 H&H Magnum Family Tree

The latest in our mini-series on famous cartridges and the chamberings they spawned. Let's take a look at .375 H&H Magnum!

New for 2026: KJI K-Series Tripods

KJI has launched an all-new K-Series tripod lineup. Replacing the original K-700 and K-800 tripods, the new K-Series represents a complete modernization of KJI's shooting support platform, offering a broader, stronger and more adaptable family of tripods built for hunting, long-range shooting, competition, photography and professional field use.

Hardware Review: Henry H17 Big Boy Deadeye Revolver

Good looks and tough construction go hand in hand with this classically styled, medium-framed wheel gun from Henry.

New for 2026: Bubba Pro Series Gen 2 Electric Fillet Knife

Bubba has introduced its Bubba Pro Series Gen 2 Electric Fillet Knife. Built from extensive feedback gathered from those who spend their time on the water, the Pro Series Gen 2 delivers enhanced ergonomics, greater control, improved cutting performance and expanded versatility than the original.

250th Anniversary Gear Roundup

Looking for some commemorative gear from America's semiquincentennial, that you'll continue to use for seasons to come? Look no further than out lineup of hunting gear celebrating America's 250th anniversary.

New for 2026: Kent Cartridge Ultimate Pheasant Load

Kent Cartridge has introduced Ultimate Pheasant, a load designed for dedicated pheasant and upland hunters. Built with Kent's proprietary Diamond Shot technology and a layered 4x6 shot payload, Ultimate Pheasant is engineered to deliver a balance of pattern density and retained energy.

Interests



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.