Member’s Hunt: Colorado Elk Odyssey

by
posted on February 24, 2025
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
MH Clint Dittmar

After 18 months of anticipation, training and planning, the time had come. We were in the Flat Tops Wilderness of Colorado. Our guide, Colton, my hunting partner, Jim, and I stood waiting, hoping and praying that the bull elk we saw minutes earlier when we entered the meadow would return.

Having been an avid whitetail hunter for over 30 years, I’ve always dreamed of going on a Western elk hunt. My passion led me to create social media pages called “Philly Burbs Bowhunters” so Philadelphia area hunters could share their successes and stories. My wonderful, amazing wife has graciously supported my hunting obsession through the years and advocated making this elk hunt a reality.

The day before the season opened, we negotiated on the way to camp Transfer Trail, which was deeply rutted, mired in mud and at some points only as wide as our vehicle. It was strewn with large rocks, fallen trees and branches. We stopped at an overlook to take in the amazing view. Little did I know at that time but across several canyons was a prominent meadow that would later be the focal point of our hunt.

The opening day of the 2024 archery season dawned on Sept. 2. The best way I can describe the hunting is to picture the steepest hill you’ve ever climbed and then imagine hiking that up, down, sideways, every three to five steps negotiating a deadfall that is knee to crotch height, while carrying your bow and daypack. Our guide, Colton, resembled a Billy goat, quickly and easily climbing the hills while Jim and I constantly lagged behind.

While walking to camp at twilight that evening, we rounded a corner and saw two enormous bull moose. We watched these magnificent animals for several minutes while they fed directly toward and behind our camp.

On Wednesday morning, we woke up to rain showers and started our hike. That afternoon we set up in a small patch of woods in a vast meadow. Colton suggested that we move farther uphill since his initial calls didn’t receive any response, and we didn’t see any movement during our glassing. As we exited the tree line, we immediately spotted a 5x5 bull about 150 yards away that had been coming in silently to Colton’s calls. He also spied us and turned to trot off in the opposite direction of his approach.  Colton directed us to dash up the steep incline of the meadow to the next patch of woods so he could see whether he could convince the bull to return. We promptly sprinted up the hill a few hundred yards and set up with Jim on the upside of the trees, Colton in the middle and me on the downside. Colton began calling again and the bull responded. He unexpectedly appeared below us in the meadow on the other side of the trees about 40 yards away. I couldn’t see him and only heard Colton frantically whisper “draw, draw, draw.” I drew back my bow and readied for the shot I had practiced thousands of times. The bull appeared broadside and stopped while staring a hole through me. I thought I completely missed the bull as I saw my arrow and lighted nock sailing on the other side of him. He turned and ran downhill, stopping broadside again while looking back. I shot again and saw that arrow land with the lighted nock sticking out of his body. He abruptly ran off the way he had come. It was about 7:20 p.m., and the three of us tried to recollect everything that had just occurred. The decision was made to leave and return the next morning. As we drove back to camp, it began violently thundering and lightning, raining and even hailing. My spirits sank realizing that any blood trail would be completely washed away by morning. That night was spent tossing, turning and staring at the top of our tent, replaying the shots in my head and wondering if we would recover the elk in the morning.

The next day, all three of us returned and started the search. About 150 yards from where the elk was standing at the last shot, I found some bull tracks and marked the spot. A few minutes later I heard Colton yell out with great excitement, “Congrats on your first Colorado bull elk!” To say I was relieved would be a complete understatement, and I was immediately overcome with gratitude, thanking God for the elk I was blessed to have killed.

The trip was everything I had dreamed of and so much more. I feel so thankful and blessed for this opportunity. I certainly couldn’t have done it without the support of my family, friends, the outfitter, our guide, Colton, Jim and most importantly God.

Latest

Lead Photo 02
Lead Photo 02

Head to Head: 7x57mm Mauser vs. .30-06 Springfield

I’ve had more than a few requests for this Head to Head, so I figured it was high time to pit two of the early 20th century’s most popular military cartridges against one another. Let's dive into the 7x57mm Mauser vs. the .30-06 Springfield.

NRA Hunter Education FREE Online Course Now Available in Louisiana

The National Rifle Association of America’s award-winning free Hunter Education online course is now available in the State of Louisiana, the latest addition as NRA works to make the course available to hunters in all 50 states.

Moultrie Updates Line of Game Feeders

Moultrie has expanded the capacity of its line of feeders, and bettered the cameras' integration with the company's connected technology to streamline the feeding process.

Building the Ultimate Elk Bow

Elk are remarkable creatures that dwell in some of the most hellish landscapes on earth. An elk bow needs to be tough, light, and ultra-accurate. Here's how to build the right one for you.

First Look: Spandau S2 20-Gauge

Spandau Arms, a brand of SDS Arms, has announced that the  Spandau S2 Shotgun is now available in a 20-gauge model in both a Mossy Oak Bottomland and a traditional wood finish.

Count Some Quail, Tally Some Turkeys

The Arkansas turkey season ended in May, but there’s still good reason for hunters and outdoor enthusiasts to keep the birds in mind when they head out to their favorite hiking trail or drive the backroads of The Natural State. Outdoorsmen who scare up coveys of quail are welcome in the survey as well.

Interests



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.