Member's Hunt: The Wrong Place at the Wrong Time

by
posted on May 21, 2022
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
MH Brownlee Lead

By Avin Brownlee, Friendswood, Texas

In the March 2021 edition of American Hunter, the “Member’s Hunt” story was titled “The Right Place, Right Time.” My story is titled “The Wrong Place at the Wrong Time.” The story begins at least 55 years ago, perhaps more. My youngest brother, Mike (10 or 12 years old at the time), wanted me to take him quail hunting. Mike had probably hunted a little with our dad but he was certainly not an experienced hunter.

We were hunting about 40 miles north of Amarillo. This was cattle country with dry grass, rolling hills and bluffs, lots of dry creek beds, scattered wild plum thickets and a few tree-lined, spring-fed creeks. Mike was carrying a single-shot .410-bore shotgun and I was carrying a beautiful, highly engraved 20-gauge, straight-grip side-by-side French shotgun that Dad had “liberated” and brought home from Europe after World War II. We were walking parallel to each other about 100-150 yards apart; Mike was heading toward a big plum thicket. Suddenly there was a BAM! I ran to the plum thicket only to find Mike standing there with his head hanging down and looking quite dejected. He had spotted and shot into a large covey of quail huddled together on the ground under a big plum bush. He did not hit a single bird. Needless to say, I teased him quite a bit about not being able to hit a single bird while the whole bunch of them were sitting still on the ground. Mike would have none of that; he blamed it on the gun and refused to hunt again until he got a better gun.

I wasn’t about to let him use the 20-gauge since I expected to inherit it someday and wanted to protect it. A couple of days later our dad borrowed a 12-gauge pump from a neighbor, so Mike was excited to try again. I insisted that he practice a little with the 12-gauge before actually hunting. So, we took a few empty cans to the country for him to shoot at and get the feel of the pump action. The recoil of the first shot surprised him and pushed him back a couple of steps. But after he was finally able to hit a can that I tossed into the air, he was raring to go.

We then returned to the site of the first hunt and set up the same way we had before. Mike had already walked through the plum thicket, across a dry creek bed and was walking through dry grass when I heard BAM! BAM! BAM! Mike hollered, “Avin, come quick. I got three, I got three!” I thought, “Yeah, sure.” I walked over to him and started helping him look for the birds. We looked, and looked and looked. I started teasing him about imagining seeing the birds fall. He insisted that he had seen three birds fall. We continued looking for what seemed like a long time and finally Mike yelled, “There’s one,” and ran over and picked up a bloody, still warm but very dead red-headed woodpecker. That is when the teasing really started. We did continue to look and finally found Mike’s two dead quail. After that day, Mike became the best shot in the family (we had four hunters) and he always outshot me at least two-to-one. We have gone on many hunts together, mostly quail or pheasant and occasionally turkey. Except for one time, Mike always got more birds than me or anyone else in the group. Strange as it may seem, I could only find one picture of us hunting together. That is Mike on the right, helping me hold my turkey, the only time I shut him out. 

This story has two endings. The first is about the 20-gauge. That beautiful gun was stolen when our parents’ house was burglarized years later. Many years later, I found a similar gun at a gun show in Houston, Texas. Even though it was not as nice as Dad’s, I bought it and presented it to him for Christmas. He was up in years then and didn’t really hunt much anymore so he gave it back to me. So, in a way, I did inherit that old French double-barrel. Along with it, I hunt with an old Browning Auto-5 recoil shotgun and an even older Swedish Husqvarna underlever 12-gauge side-by-side. They are all fun to shoot.

This story’s second ending concerns the woodpecker. Even though Mike is a great hunter, I occasionally have to remind him that the first “game animal” he harvested with a gun was that poor, innocent red-headed woodpecker who was unfortunately in the wrong place at the wrong time.


Do you have an exciting, unusual or humorous hunting experience to share? 
Send your story (800 words or less) to [email protected] or to American Hunter, Dept. MH, 11250 Waples Mill Road, Fairfax, VA. 22030-9400. Please include your NRA ID number. Good quality photos are welcome. Make sure you have permission to use the material. Authors will not be paid, and manuscripts and photos will not be returned. All material becomes the property of NRA.

Latest

SHOT LEDE
SHOT LEDE

Wildest Hunting Finds of SHOT 2026

This year's SHOT Show was a reminder that creativity and innovation within the hunting world are alive and well. Here are ten items that caused us to take a double-take whilst walking the show floor.

Hot from SHOT: Best Whitetail Gear for 2026

With the new year comes a wave of newly released hunting gear aimed at giving hunters the edge afield. From cozier tree stands, easy-to-pack bags, feed, blinds, and more, manufacturers have sought every imaginable way to help hunters become more successful on their hunts. Read on as we take a closer look at what caught our eye.

AH Hunts: Late Season Alberta Geese Pt. 2

With some birds on the ground, Jon and Brad take a second to discuss the size of late-season Alberta honkers, before diving into the guns that brought them down. Check out part 2 of Senior Executive Editor Jon Draper and American Hunter contributor Brad Fenson's late-season Alberta honker hunt here.

Hardware Review: Hornady Backcountry Defense

A casual hike, a quick trip to grab firewood or a morning spent chasing trout all carry the potential of encountering a furry threat that might want to remind you that you are no longer at the top of the hierarchy.

Ruger Announces American Rifle Generation II Scout Models

Ruger ups the ante in 2026, delivering a newly crafted Scout rifle under its increasingly popular American Gen II line.

New for 2026: Hawke Optics Vantage IR 1-4x20mm in Mossy Oak Bottomland

Purpose-built to give turkey hunters fast target acquisition, precise shot placement and a camo pattern that blends seamlessly into the Spring woods, Hawke's latest LVPO is designed to impress.

Interests



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.