Mehall's Top 10 Shotguns

by
posted on June 1, 2009
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
200961-top10shotgun_fs.jpg

1.) Remington 870
With nearly 10 million and counting in the hands of American hunters, has anything taken more game with the mere swap of an indestructible barrel? This multi-purpose American classic is reliable, affordable and so versatile it's also a top choice for home defense and even holds its own with clay targets, as the legendary Rudy Etchen proved.

2.) Browning Auto-5
Revolutionary as the first mass-produced, recoil-operated shotgun, John Browning's uniquely recognizable design was the gun of choice for notables from World War II flying ace and former NRA President Joe Foss to General George S. Patton.



3.) Beretta 680 Series
Kyle was two for two, but his No. 8 is my No. 3. Since launching this innovative, lightweight line in the 1980s, Beretta has been churning out models in various grades ever since. Elegant, easy to swing and not as costly as some finer options, these may be the best mass-produced over/unders available, from the 682 to the simple-but-elegant 686.

4.) Browning Superposed
Though heavy for some, the first affordable over/under turned enough heads to pull more than a few American hunters away from their prized pumps.




5.) Winchester Model 12
Dubbed the "perfect repeater" in 1912, this classic is the most famous American pump of all time, raising the bar for what was to come.

6.) Benelli Super Black Eagle
Based on the M1 Super 90, this gun was the first 31/2-inch option for semi-autos.




7.) Winchester Model 21
Production of this gun even outlasted that of the Parker. And how unique that it's loaded by lifting the barrel to insert shells at the breech. 




8.) Purdey Game Gun
More sophisticated and of better quality than Holland & Holland, Purdey represents all British side-by-sides. The name set the standard by which all other British guns were judged and will hold its place in time. 




9.) Parker Invincible
Clark Gable may have owned an L.C. Smith, but he cherished his Parkers. And what a following this vintage American double maintains. Though Parkers came in more grades and sizes than any other American double, they're a challenge to collect.




10.) Fabbri Ornamental 8SQS

If I were covering the top 10 musical instruments I'd include a Stradavarius, so here I'll include a gun in a class of its own. A Fabbri shotgun melds ancient artisan skills with modern technology. It will hold its position over time, thanks to state-of-the-art, precision parts of stainless steel and titanium alloy. This gun is not only the best fitting or most finely engraved, but the most reliable and durable-it will never break. Says Ivo Fabbri: "Rome lasted 1,000 years. Shouldn't a Fabbri?"

Latest

BTB 7Mm RUM Lead
BTB 7Mm RUM Lead

Behind the Bullet: 7mm Remington Ultra Magnum

Launching a 160-grain bullet in excess of 3200 fps, the 7mm RUM is among the fastest commercially loaded 7mm cartridges available.

USFWS Debuts 2025-2026 Federal and Junior Duck Stamps

The 2025-2026 Federal Migratory Bird Hunting and Conservation Stamp—commonly known as the Duck Stamp—became available for purchase on June 27, 2025.

Tested: Work Sharp Professional Precision Adjust Elite Knife Sharpener

Digital Associate Editor walks viewers through the features of the Work Sharp Professional Precision Adjust Elite Knife Sharpener, the perfect tool for a hunter looking to keep all his knives factory sharp season after season.

Recipe: Green Curried Black Bear

Green curry sauce is an excellent base for simmering bear meat, making it flavorful, tender, and safe to consume. Read on for another instant classic recipe from Brad Fenson.

Coyotes to Competitions: An AR-Build for Accuracy

ARs make great coyote guns. But what would the absolute best coyote rifle look like? Digital Associate Editor David Herman builds his take on the best AR for shooters who like to plug coyotes in the winter, and ring steel all summer long.

Pennsylvania Governor Signs Sunday Hunting Bill

Legislation that will fully repeal Pennsylvania’s Sunday hunting ban was signed into law on July 9.

Interests



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.