When to Call Elk—or Not!

by
posted on October 2, 2014
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
mehall_ah2015_fs.jpg (51)

When bowhunting elk, knowing when not to call is just as important as knowing when to call. What I do depends on the given scenario and whether I simply want to get a branch-antlered bull or I’d like a shot at the herd bull.

Cameraman Rex Summerfield and I were just debating when to call on Saturday while sitting all day in a Primos Double Bull blind at a Colorado waterhole filming for “Phil Phillips Unleashed.” Early that morning, I wanted to skip calling and try stalking the herd bull, but this particular property held hundreds of elk--and many sets of elk eyes that could too easily pick up two people and a videocam. So we stayed in the blind, hoping a cow would drag in a big bull or that one of the nice satellite bulls caught on the Moultrie and Cuddeback trail-cams would get thirsty.

By mid-morning, we’d tried everything from bugles to cow and calf calls. Bulls screamed from their beds, but they weren’t budging, not even to check out the super whiny cow calls we made to mimic the sound of a cow being harassed by a bull. By evening, the bulls began screaming again and moved closer. While it was tempting to call, we remained silent because the action was picking up on its own. Two young bulls came in and sparred right in front of us then two more came in for a drink. Another bugling bull was on its way so we never made a peep and let the elk do what they wanted to do. Two minutes later, a 6X6 came in and I dropped him, fittingly, with an Easton FMJ at 27 yards on the 27th. Phil came to check things out just in time to be in a photo.

Moral of the story: Sometimes the best call is no call at all if you're where the elk want to be.

Latest

002 TNW1911 R Gun 01
002 TNW1911 R Gun 01

Range Review: TNW Firearms 1911 ASR: A .450 SMC Carbine?

This caliber-convertible PCC from TNW is designed for high-pressure loads other models can't touch.

New for 2026: XS Sights Tritium Standard Dot Front Sights for Ruger SP101

Ruger SP101 revolver owners can now upgrade their factory sights with XS's pre-drilled Tritium Standard Dot front sight for easier target acquisition.

Behind the Bullet: The .460 Smith & Wesson Magnum

If ever a handgun cartridge deserved the title “magnum”, the .460 Smith & Wesson Magnum is it. In the cartridge world, magnum is defined as a cartridge which provides a performance level exceeding the norm, and that is a perfect way to describe S&W’s big .460: it is at the top of the heap in the .45-caliber handgun cartridge family.

Nosler Expands Whitetail Country .30 Caliber Line

Nosler has expanded it's Whitetail Country ammunition line with two new 180-grain .30 caliber offerings. There are: .30-06 Springfield 180-grain Solid Base, and .300 Winchester Magnum 180-grain Solid Base.

Savage Model 99—The Jeep of the Gun World

Savage 99 represents a full circle of rifle design. Join Andi Bogard on a whimsical exploration of both the technical brilliance and timeless effectiveness of this iconic design. 

First Look: Arcus Hunting Defend by Tink's

Arcus Hunting has released Defend by Tink's, focused on creating the impression that coyotes are present, keeping unwanted wildlife away from homes and properties, and providing a strong, authentic urine sourced from real coyotes for real effectiveness.

Interests



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.