Experts in the Field
Whitetail Season with Bill Winke
FacebookTwitterYouTubeRSS Feed
Five Quality Shotguns for Under $500

Five Quality Shotguns for Under $500

Hunters have said it loud and clear: We are tired of reading about shotguns that cost more than a monthly mortgage payment. We heard you, and we’ve delivered.

By Doug Howlett

  • Comment
  • Send to Friend
  • Share This

3/21/2011

I grew up in a place where deer hunting—and most hunting for that matter—was limited to the use of shotguns, where the old scattergun was a staple and most hunters owned and used only one for virtually all of their hunting needs. Shotguns were tools that got beat around and used hard. They had to be durable, perform well and for the majority of us, they had to be affordable. Somewhere along the line, shotguns became like cars and trucks, with more high-performance features that, while certainly making for awesome results, also ran up the cost.

Not all of us need or want a King Ranch package F-350, when a good ole basic F-150 will get us where we need to go.

 Brand new, these shotguns will run you less than $500. Best of all, when the moment of truth arrives and the ducks, deer, turkeys or whatever slip into range, they’ll deliver the same results as a gun three times the cost.

Mossberg Model 500
Mossberg defines affordability with its shotguns and delivers workhorse performance for the budget-conscious sportsman. While looking to shave costs off of most shotguns, a buyer will often have to forego the camo (licensing costs for camo patterns typically run the price of a gun up between $40 and $70).

Mossberg

But not with Mossberg. Even in Mossy Oak New Break-Up or Advantage Max-4, the Model 500 cruises in just above the $400 mark. Capable of handling 3-inch shells, these pump-guns also boast ported barrels, synthetic stocks, an ambidextrous safety and six shot (5 + 1) capacity. The Model 500 is available in nearly 40 different configurations, running the gamut from as low as $375 up to $521. ($435)  
 
The Stoeger Model 2000
Want Benelli performance for less? Look no further than Stoeger, which doesn’t force the buyer to choose a pump-action just to keep the price in the $500 ballpark. In fact, Stoeger’s matte black Model 2000 semi-auto cruises in just under that mark. The 2000 employs the high-performing, yet simplistic Inertia Driven operating system perfected by sister company Benelli, which allows a slimmer fore-end for optimal grip and balance.

               stoeger 2000

Because gases don’t power the action, it tends to stay cleaner for those who cycle a lot of rounds. The gun accommodates loads up to 3 inches. I’ve had friends who have bought these guns, and I’ve used them myself, and for what they spent on their Stoegers, these guys are all smiles, particularly when posing in pictures with their game. ($499)
 
Remington Model 870
With more than 10 million sold since its introduction nearly a half century ago, the Remington Model 870 is arguably the best selling shotgun in history. And for good reason. It works and shoots with unfailing dependability, yet it is still priced right. The 870 Express in a classic satin and walnut finish utilizes twin action bars for smooth cycling and is available in both 12 and 20 gauges.

                Remington 870

Barrel options include either a 26- or 28-inch vent rib barrel with a Modified Rem Choke and single bead sight. While the suggested retail price for this shotgun comes in at just over $400, stroll through a Wal-Mart or other retailer during sale time and you can find this top-performer well into the low $300 range. I’ve even seen synthetic models for under that amount. Other 870 variations, including models tailored for turkeys, waterfowl and even slugsters for deer, all cruise below the $500 radar. ($411)
 
Benelli Nova Pump
Who says you can’t get genuine Benelli quality as well as the name at a cost that doesn’t range into four figures? The Benelli Nova in matte black boasts the same lightweight, slender styling of the company’s high-dollar, highly sought semi-auto offerings by incorporating a polymer stock and light receiver into a single unit.

                    Benelli Nova

Dual-action bars and rotary head locking lugs ensure reliable performance with load capability running the gamut from light target shot shells to 3 ½-inch magnum shoulder breakers. Twenty-gauge models tip the scales at a mere 6 ½ pounds, while 12 gauges weigh in at a pound and a half more. The shotgun comes with three chokes: improved cylinder, modified and full. ($439)
 
H&R Tracker II Slug Gun
Not every shotgun hunter is looking to spray and pray. For those deer hunting diehards that know the first shot is truly the one that counts, Harrington & Richardson is known for its single-shot tack drivers. The Tracker II, like all H&Rs, is built stout with a strong break-action lock-up and heavy barrel with Utragon Rifling that is created using six oval lands and grooves minus the sharp corners common to traditional rifling.

HR Tracker

The end result is accuracy out to the farthest performance limits of modern slug loads. The Tracker II comes with a hardwood stock in walnut finish, adjustable rifle sights and prefixed sling swivel studs. It is without peer in the affordability department. ($223)

  • Comment
  • Send to Friend
  • Share This

Comments

  • BuddyinLouisiana

    1/16/2012 12:27:34 PM

    I thought the remington 870 would be the best choice at $299. not so. It will not eject the shells properly, no matter what I do. And don't think I'm an isolated case. google it. Going to buy a Benelli now. Should have done that in the first place

  • mikeintexas

    12/27/2011 3:19:39 PM

    I bought an 870 Wingmaster in the early 80's and it is still working fine. I bought the Stoeger 2000 in camo in 2005. I have put thousands of rounds through each and no trouble from either.

  • bryand

    12/17/2011 3:09:50 PM

    Hey you forgot the winchester SXP, I got one and love it, only wish I could get a rifled slug barrel for it

  • JIm M

    11/27/2011 8:35:11 AM

    Picked up a Stoeger 2000 a few years ago to use strictly for dog hunting deer, which puts heavy abuse on your gun. Not only does it get thrown in and out of the truck a hundred times a day, it gets thrown up on the dogbox, sometimes forgetting it and driving off, thereby throwing it off on the ground or into the mud. Now you see why I do not take any of my high priced "B" guns dog hunting. Well, the Stoeger 2000 has taken everything that has been thrown at it in stride. I call it my little Timex. "It takes a licking, and keeps on shooting".

  • kenneth Y

    10/6/2011 7:57:02 PM

    Thanks for the great articles. This is exactly what I was looking for. I want to get my first shotgun and in today's day and age it is definitely a plus to find an article concerned about quality as well as price! Perhaps some advice from Doug or anyone else? My local Gun store sells the 870 express. Is that drastically different from the 870 in your article? can get it for 259 with rebates. I like the Beneli mentioned (cant afford the SBE) but am torn you informed me the stoeger was an semi for basically the same price...Any thoughts guys?

  • John R.

    7/30/2011 8:04:07 AM

    I am on my 2nd 870. For the price and performance, you can't beat it.

  • Chuck K.

    6/25/2011 7:28:35 AM

    I owned a Mossberg 500A for almost 20 years ($200). Great gun - no issues. I then moved to an autoloader, a Traditions ALS2100 ($350). Again, no issues. I also now own a Remington 870 and Smith and Wesson Autoloader - both won at gun raffles, all $500 or less and all great guns.

  • Will

    6/21/2011 8:42:08 PM

    I have had my 870 for many years pumped alot of shells through it,takes a beating been worth every penny.

  • Glen

    5/29/2011 8:34:43 AM

    I purchased a Mossberg 500 Deer/Upland combo for my brother in 1992 for $199. He still has that same gun and has used it every deer and pheasant season since. I've never known a person to kill more pheasants, quail, partridge than him. I bought one for myself 7 years ago ($285) mainly for deer hunting and between my brother and I we have killed more deer than the other 7 guys in our camp combined. I'll match my Mossberg 500 up against any slug gun in the market. It defines true value for the money. I also bought a 935 for waterfowl. A few years ago it was the only gun in the blind that didn't misfire. The other 3 guns (2 Benelli's and a Beretta) all misfired at least twice. I'm a Mossberg guy for life.

  • Spirit of '76

    5/28/2011 11:25:31 AM

    My 870 is the worst piece of crap l've ever owned. lt doesn't feed or eject, and the gunsmith said it'd cost more to fix than it's worth. Which ain't much. Oh, and the stock is loose. Except when it's raining and it swells up.

  • Sam

    5/26/2011 6:40:34 PM

    Bought my first 870 in 1954. I've tried other guns but keep going back to the 870, for everything, skeet, quail, turkey ducks, etc. I've owned at least 15 over the yrs. but I'm down to 5 now & own nothing but 870's.

  • Brent

    5/23/2011 5:39:38 PM

    I know my camo 535 was only $319 at dicks with a red dot and 2 barrels(waterfoul and cantilever turkey) last year. How can you beat that? It's very similar to the 500 but I can shoot 3.5" shells. For the price of that combo, I have nothing to complain about.

  • Ro

    5/23/2011 12:55:25 PM

    don't forget about weatherby's pa-08's. msrp synthetic $329, upland model $409!

  • Bo

    4/19/2011 8:21:02 AM

    The BPS is a better made gun than most of these, and on par with the 870. It should have not been omitted. I don't own one, but my buddies do, I'm impressed with it and I think it's a great shotgun. I own one 870, made while they were still under DuPont. The newer ones, particularly the Express, are cheaply made with plastic triggerguards and MIM parts. I'd rather pick an older used shotgun any day of the week over those noted in this article. Give me an old Ithaca M37, a used Model 12, or an older 870 any day. They will all last a few generations if cared for. I learned decades ago that if you buy a cheap gun, you get a cheap gun.

  • Danny Garrett

    3/25/2011 5:41:31 PM

    I am one of the 10m who bought the Remington 870. I purchased it back about 1968. I used if for deer, squriel, quail and rabbit. I could pump out buck shot as fast as any auto. Or just just one when it was only needed. I havent used it in years hoping to keep it for one of my son's. I am so glad I purchased this shotgun.