Combining Calls for Turkey-Hunting Success

posted on April 17, 2023

For many, many years I have been touting the importance of being proficient with as many different types of turkey calls as possible. The versatility of using several calls makes you much more effective as the gobbler’s preferences are not consistent and can change from one day to the next.

4-Play on turkey

I hunt one particular property where I have documented that the gobblers do not respond well to the box call. I have worked a half-dozen toms into sight with a 4-Play box call without getting a shot. Every time I switched to my slate call, I walked out with a gobbler over my shoulder. I have had other hunts where the only call a bird would answer was a diaphragm call. The pitch of each call is unique, and sometimes only a certain pitch will work.

There is also a distinct advantage in using two different calls on the same hunt. A great example of this happened just a couple of years ago with me and my middle stepson, Spencer. Spencer now lives and works in Chicago, and only gets home a few times each year. One of those times is always to turkey hunt. I think I was looking forward to our time together in the woods as much as he was.

I scouted one of our favorite spots and set-up a blind, just in case it was raining the only day Spencer had to hunt. Coming home on Easter weekend is a very busy time and Saturday morning was his only window to get with a gobbler. I wanted to give him every possible advantage.

We got to the blind plenty early and got the decoys out well before the first gobble. When the toms woke up there was a gobbler several hundred yards north of us, and two or three screaming toms roughly as far to our self.  Since we were already set, we decided to go ahead and try calling from the blind.

Over the next hour, many calls and many gobbles culminated in absolutely nothing. The birds hit the ground, found their strut zones and stayed put. They would gobble on their own and even answer Spence’s 4-Play box call, but they would not move. Sometimes, the best thing to do with toms that will not budge is go to them. So we did.

Spencer wanted to make a move to the south to put us closer to the greater number of gobbling toms. I knew of a bottom field along the creek that would easily split the distance between us and the turkeys. We made the move quickly and quietly, and were set at 7:30. There had not been a gobble since just before we moved.

We put out three decoys. I use a strutting jake called the B-Mobile from Primos and two real hen decoys.  I also put a real fan on the jake, making the decoy spread irresistible to mature gobblers. Jakes will come to them too, but adult toms hate seeing a jake with two hens in the spring.

Spencer made a couple of calling sequences with his box with no response. The toms had shut down gobbling completely. It was deadly quiet. I knew hens had been on nests for a couple weeks, so I was confident they were not henned-up. We just had to exercise some patience … or not.

About 15-minutes from the time we sat down, a gobble rang out from about 150-yards down the creek. Spencer played hard to get and did not answer. A few minutes passed, and Spence made a few light yelps on the box. The tom answered immediately from about 100-yards. My young partner put the call down and picked up his gun.

This was a very smart move for two reasons—first, getting caught by a gobbler with your gun in your lap is inexcusable. Second, he knew I was 10-yards behind him with the video camera and could make another call if needed. Just seconds later Spencer turned his head slightly and whispered that the gobbler was in the field.

Spencer and Mike with Turkey

I saw the tom strutting at about 85-yards. He was turning circles as he spit and drummed trying to intimidate the jake and attract the hens. I picked-up my slate call and made three gobbler clucks. The tom’s reaction was priceless. Staying in full-strut he ran toward the decoys as fast as he could in that position.

He slowed down at 50-yards and I clucked twice more. Now he was totally committed and came right to the three impersonators. Spencer had his 12-gauge magnum loaded with Federal’s #7-shot turkey loads. The huge black bird was strutting between the hens when I made a single putt with my voice. When he raised his head to look, Spencer’s shot went right through it.

At 8:05AM on Spencer Dietrich’s only day to hunt spring gobblers, he put a 23.5-pound bird with an 11-inch beard on the ground. Hugs and high-fives were followed by a short photo session. I had a smile from ear-to-ear when Spencer said, “We’re still a pretty good team.”

My best advice is to get proficient with as many types of calls as you can. There is no predicting exactly what the gobblers will respond to on any given day. Be prepared and get confident with all your calls.


How To Hunt Silent Elk Lead
How To Hunt Silent Elk Lead

How to Hunt Silent Elk

To hunt elk that give you the silent treatment, you must focus on necessities they need all year: water, food and refuge from predators.

NRA to Celebrate “Wild Game Meat Donation Month” in November

This November, the NRA and its members will celebrate the first-ever “Wild Game Meat Donation Month” to encourage all hunters to donate extra venison or other game meat to help provide meals for those in need.

Longtime NRA Supporter Michael Fuljenz Honored With American Numismatic Association’s Highest Award

NRA Golden Ring of Freedom member Michael Fuljenz, is the 2023 recipient of the highest honor bestowed by the Congressionally-chartered American Numismatic Association.

Review: Marlin Model 336 Classic

A handsome lever-action chambered in .30-30 Winchester, the Marlin Model 336 Classic is smooth, precise, accurate and has a great wood-to-metal fit.

Head to Head: 6.5 PRC vs. .308 Winchester

We put two short-action gems up against one another: the .308 Winchester, a time-proven veteran with 70-plus years of hunting experience, and the 6.5 PRC, a relative newcomer that is quickly gaining favor in the hunting fields and target range.

Remington Issues Safety Recall on Several Lots of .300 Win. Mag. Ammo

Remington is recalling three lots of 300 Win. Mag. Core-Lokt Tipped ammunition. The affected boxes may contain incorrect propellant and use may result in firearm damage and/or personal injury.


Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.