The Pros and Cons of an Over/Under for Ducks

by
posted on July 26, 2013
dogs_ah2015_fs.jpg (22)

For several waterfowl seasons I’ve tossed around the idea of swapping my autoloader for a double gun. This year I may finally get serious about it. My grandfather has gifted me an old Franchi over/under, and I relish the idea of sending him a photo of me holding his shotgun and a brace of mallards. Still, I’m torn as to what to do. As I see it, here are the pros and cons of shooting an over/under in the duck blind.

Pros:

Shootability
I don’t know why, but I’ve just always shot a double barrel better than a pump or autoloader. Do they balance better? Some say so, but I think it boils down more to personal preference.

No Side-Ejection
An over/under doesn’t eject shells into your buddy’s face or scatter them haphazardly, requiring cleanup.

Class/Nostalgia
Call me a snob if you will, but to my eye no firearm surpasses the beauty of an over/under shotgun. Plus, before there were magazine guns, there were only sidelocks. A gun with two barrels is a connection to waterfowling’s past.

Cons:

Two Shots Only
I don’t often use my semi-auto’s third shell to shoot a duck from the sky. They’re typically out of range by then. But it sure comes in handy for giving ducks the coup de grace on the water.

Durability
If you want something to rust or get dinged up, take it duck hunting. I don’t worry about getting my magazine guns covered in salt spray or caked in mud—that’s what I bought them for and their synthetic stocks are built to handle it. However, most over/unders—including grandpa’s—have wood stocks and blued barrels. Many are also expensive, but with grandpa’s gun I’m mostly concerned about the sentimental value—I do not want to destroy it.

Shine
Most of today’s magazine guns for duck hunting reduce shine with blackened finishes or camo dips. Most over/unders sport blued barrels and often oiled wood finishes. Fancy, shiny guns don’t exactly keep a low profile for all those eyes in the sky.

Given my indecisiveness, I say we take a vote: Should I take grandpa’s over/under duck hunting? Have you ever shot ducks with a double-barreled shotgun?

Latest

33 Winchester Old Box
33 Winchester Old Box

Behind the Bullet: .33 Winchester

Phil Massaro dives into the history and performance of the .33 Winchester.

New for 2025: Springfield Armory Model 2020 Heatseeker

Springfield Armory has announced the Springfield Armory Model 2020 Heatseeker, a compact chassis-based rifle crafted for shooters who demand bolt-action precision and AR-style modularity in one uncompromising, suppressor-ready platform.

Selway Wilderness Outfitters: Your Gateway to the Backcountry

Looking for a new place to chase elk, deer, bear, mountain lion or wolvers, or even do some fishing in the offseason? Want to do it in the heart of Idaho's backcountry, far from towns or even road access? Check out Selway Wilderness Outfitters.

Hardware Review: Taurus Expedition

After a year of testing the Expedition and using it afield, contributor Jeff Johnston believes it’s one of the best compact, hunting/target shooting/utility rifles available for less than $700.

Tested: G9 Defense's Woodsman and EHP Ammunition

These monolithic metal handgun bullets provide an alternative to hollow points for fans of the great outdoors.

NRA Takes Fight to Defend Constitutional Rights of Young Adults to U.S. Supreme Court

SCOTUS petitioned to hear challenge to Florida’s ban on firearm purchases by adults under 21.

Interests



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.