HSUS' Lawsuit to Silence Maine Wildlife Professionals Dismissed

by
posted on April 28, 2015
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
black_bear_hlf_f.jpg

On Friday, Apr. 3, Maine Superior Court Justice Joyce Wheeler issued a final judgment in the question of the state’s ability to comment on wildlife issues. In her ruling, Wheeler sided with the U.S. Sportsmen's Alliance (USSA) and dismissed an HSUS (Humane Society of the United States) lawsuit designed to prevent Maine wildlife professionals from speaking out on wildlife issues.

The case started in the closing weeks of the Maine bear campaign over Question 1 on the November 2014 ballot. The HSUS, through their front group Mainers for Fair Bear Hunting, sued the state of Maine—in this case the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife—alleging an improper level of engagement as the department’s vocal and public opposition to Question 1 didn't mesh with HSUS’ mission to stop bear hunting statewide.

The original lawsuit sought an injunction that would remove the TV advertisements being aired by the Maine Wildlife Conservation Council that featured department personnel talking about the dangers of Question 1.

“Political campaigns are won and lost on TV, especially in the case of ballot issue campaigns,” said Evan Heusinkveld, USSA Foundation’s vice president of government affairs. “There is no doubt our opponents saw the wildlife management professionals at the department as a distinct threat to their campaign. In response, they attempted to silence the only true experts—the professional staff at the Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife.”

On Oct. 22, 2014, Maine Superior Court Justice Joyce Wheeler denied the request for a temporary restraining order by Mainers for Fair Bear Hunting, which sought to remove television commercials opposed to Question 1. In her ruling, Justice Wheeler sided with the right of the state to provide comment. This ensured the commercials remained on the air, and just a few days later sportsmen were victorious at the ballot box, defeating Question 1 by a 53-46 margin. Despite the victory on the temporary restraining order and at the ballot box on Nov. 4, the lawsuit remained active.

In light of judge’s decision and with the election over, on Feb. 24 the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife moved to have the case dismissed because of mootness—a move supported by Maine Wildlife Conservation Council. However, HSUS lawyer Rachel Wertheime countered that the lawsuit was still valid because the organization would be filing paperwork to put a bear-hunting-ban initiative on the state’s 2016 ballot.

In her ruling today, Justice Wheeler responded to that motion by fully and finally dismissing the case at the Superior Court level, leaving HSUS, and their group Mainers for Fair Bear Hunting with few options outside of appeal to the state’s Law (Superior) Court.

“The Superior court already ruled that the state was well within its right to speak out on this issue, and now they have now decided that since the election is over, the case is moot,” said Heusinkveld.  “This ruling just reaffirms our position and is a clear victory for sportsmen and women.” There is no doubt the people of Maine deserve to hear from the experts on such issues!

Latest

LEDE Rewards For New Hunter Ed
LEDE Rewards For New Hunter Ed

IHEA-USA Announces New Hunter Rewards Program and Investigation Instructor Academy

The International Hunter Education Association–USA (IHEA-USA), in partnership with Guidefitter, has launched PathPerks, a reward and recognition program designed for new hunter education graduates.

Remington Announces 4th Annual Shoot to Cure Fundraiser

Remington Ammunition will be hosting its 4th Annual Shoot to Cure sporting clays fundraiser on September 19, 2025.

Recipe: Venison Crostini with Smoky Berry-Spice Chimichurri

This venison crostini is more than a recipe, it’s a celebration of the hunt and the flavors it provides. Read on for how to make one all your own.

New for 2025: Browning Defender Vision Pro Livestream

The Defender Vision Pro Livestream from Browning Trail Cameras puts hunters in the middle of the action as it happens via the Strike Force Wireless app.

Hardware Review: Smith & Wesson 1854 Stealth Hunter

A modern cowboy ought to have a modern lever-action rifle. That’s one reason Senior Executive Editor Jon Draper was so excited to get his hands on the latest lever gun from Smith and Wesson, the 1854 Stealth Hunter. Read on for his thorough review.

First Look: GoView Zoomr 10x42 Binocular

GoView USA has announced the introduction of its Zoomr 10x42mm binocular, designed specifically for situations where brilliant image quality is essential.

Interests



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.