How Do You Compare Riflescopes?

by
posted on December 16, 2014

The Quandary
On a fairly regular basis, I am sent riflescopes for testing and evaluation. Testing objective factors such as the accuracy of adjustments, durability and eye relief is a relatively straightforward process. That said, testing optical quality can be really difficult without sophisticated testing equipment (which I don't have).

The Question
How do you objectively compare and evaluate the subjective qualities of a riflescope?  Until recently, the only way for me to evaluate factors such as optical clarity and light transmission was by mounting the scope to a rifle and taking it (and a few other rifle/scope combos) outside in various lighting conditions. At dusk, for example, I could take turns looking through scopes at a 1951 Air Force Resolution Target and see which scope gave me the best performance in the diminished light. The problem was that by the time you switched rifles and scopes, your brain "forgot" exactly what the previous image looked like. Not a perfect system to say the least.

The Solution
A few months ago, a box showed up at my door—sent by a well-known gunsmith friend. It was a steel bar, fitted with four different scope rings set side-by-side. The bar allowed for up to four scopes to be mounted and adjusted so that they all shared the same point of aim. The entire package can be mounted on a camera tripod so that the evaluator (me) can sit comfortably for long periods of time behind the glass. By moving my head an inch or so in each direction, I can compare scopes on the same plane, focused on the same target, in the same conditions. As dusk falls, I can quickly move back and forth between images, comparing apples to apples. Simple, but very effective.

Nothing groundbreaking here, but a little window into what methods we use to evaluate products.

Latest

Benelli SBE3 28 Gauge 3 Inch Lead
Benelli SBE3 28 Gauge 3 Inch Lead

New for 2022: Benelli SBE3 28-Gauge, 3-Inch

For 2022, Benelli raises the bar in the growing sub-gauge movement with the release of the 28-gauge Super Black Eagle 3, featuring a 3-inch chamber.

Winchester Debuts Bismuth Waterfowl Ammunition

Winchester's Bismuth brings to market a premium, uniform shot, which is tin-plated to produce smooth and round bismuth.

First Look: Rock River Arms Predator HP LAR-BT3

Chambered in the venerable .243 Winchester, the new Predator HP LAR-BT3 is field ready and capable of MOA accuracy.

First Look: TNT T-Rex Pro Treestand in Realtree Edge Camo

Weighing in at just 21 pounds, the True North Treestands (TNT) T-Rex self-climber in Realtree Edge camo is a stand-up/sit-down style all-aluminum stand that features True North's new patent-pending "T-Rex” toothed dual-cable design and the Rapid Claw attachment system.

First Look: Primos Trigger Stick Apex Carbon Fiber Tripod

With carbon-fiber-wrapped aluminum legs and a solid Apex-Clamp design, the Trigger Stick Apex Carbon Fiber Tripod allows firearms or crossbows to be secured to it.

Browning Introduces New A5 Sweet Sixteen Shotguns

Browning’s A5 Sweet Sixteen lineup grows with several new models for designed for upland and waterfowl hunting.

Interests



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.