Nebraska Whitetails Rising

posted on September 25, 2012

If the University of Nebraska football team was the Whitetails, deer hunting might get more attention in the Cornhusker State. Alas, when the school chose its team nickname, whitetails were probably as rare as moose in this prairie state.

Well, not anymore.

“How about that one?” my guide, Justin Nott, asked as we huddled beside his truck in north-central Nebraska, buffeted by both the 14-degree northern breeze and the roar of grain trucks passing on the highway.

“The 5x5 walking behind that doe along the fence?” I asked.

“No, the bigger one to the north. In the corner. Just came out of the trees by those six does and the 4x4 we were watching earlier.”

I swung the spotting scope toward the north. Like hay bales in an alfalfa field, deer after deer flickered through my view before I found a broad-chested, thick-necked buck laboring across the milo field under an impressive supply of thick, wide, heavy bone.

“Oh yeah, that might do,” I said.

“Well, the one we’re looking for is bigger.”

Justin, a Nebraska native, had returned to his home state in 2010 after a seven-year stint in the U.S. Air Force and began taking orders at Laughing Water Ranch Outfitters (LWRO) from Lance Kuck. Kuck is steering his bison ranch near Bassett toward the highest-quality hunting for free-range turkeys, grouse, quail, waterfowl, mule deer and whitetail deer, and Justin is his first officer.

“The kid is obsessed with managing this place for wildlife,” Lance told me last November during my second hunt with his outfit. “He’s taking soil samples, fertilizing, putting out mineral supplements, planting food plots in the river bottom, hanging trail cameras and literally cataloging every buck on the place.”

I can attest to the cataloging. When I walked into camp last fall for my second hunt with LWRO, I discovered dozens of trail camera photos of bucks Justin had captured and posted on the bunkhouse wall. Each animal had been given a name. Several, already shot by bowhunters before my arrival, had their scores added to the photos. Every hunter in camp was studying this dream gallery, selecting their favorites, all of which appeared to score 150 or more. “Heck,” I said after several minutes’ reverie. “I’d be happy with any of them.” And I was.

But I’m getting ahead of myself. During my first hunt with LWRO two years ago, there was no photo gallery. Justin just described bucks he’d been seeing then showed me them, live and on the hoof—a 140-class buck cruising a tree strip here, three 130-class bucks harassing a dozen does over there, a tall 4x4 eating alfalfa next to a fence, a 170-inch bruiser running from the middle of the grassland behind us.

“Where the heck did he come from?” I asked over the howling wind after the heavy buck and several does had disappeared over a rise.

“Must have been lying in that low spot we just passed.”

“That’s nothing but grass!”

“Didn’t seem to matter to him.”

“Him” was not just a big buck, but the big buck—the slippery giant Justin had glimpsed and had tried to corner all season. He’d pinned him down to an isolated, old grove of homestead trees clinging to life deep in the grasslands a mile from the nearest road where no sane hunter would look. But grassland whitetails aren’t sane. We were heading to the old grove when the buck caught us flat-footed in the open. There tomorrow, here today. Plains whitetails do crazy, out-of-character stuff like bed in a grassy swale. As we’d trudged toward the trees where he was supposed to be, our heads bowed against the wind, we’d walked right past him.

Nebraska whitetails are rather adept at living with lots of grass and minimal tree cover. Coyote hunter Lyndon Branson and I almost walked right through another big, grassland buck in west-central Nebraska once. We’d crossed a sandy hill, one of millions here, to surprise a whole herd of whitetails. At least three bucks and a half-dozen does scattered like quail, flickering through a thin strip of trees and clumps of tall grass, jumping fences and leaping yucca plants. Normally I study bucks with a binocular if not a spotting scope before shooting, but this one needed no study. It was wide, tall and handsome. Lyndon didn’t have to hiss, “Shoot that one!” but he did anyway. It didn’t appear I’d get the chance—until romance interrupted the escape. Four skips and a jump from crossing a ridge, one of the does turned back and stopped by a fence. The buck stopped to wait for her.

“Three hundred seventy yards!” Lyndon advised. I steadied the Mossberg 100 ATR over the stag’s shoulder, showing a bit of daylight under the reticle, and sent a 95-grain .243 Ballistic Silvertip his way. The 163-gross buck collapsed in his tracks.

While a spectacular buck, this one wasn’t likely to raise eyebrows at the local check station. These days Nebraskans are used to quality deer for at least three reasons: Bedding and escape cover have caught up to the forage base; landowners are willing to tolerate high deer populations and the crop depredation that comes with it (hay stacks in deep-snow winters suffer most); and biologists are managing the harvest to allow more bucks to grow old. (Or maybe the escape cover is now so dense that more bucks can escape.)

A little history is in order. Traditionally Nebraska was a vast bison prairie sitting on the western edge of whitetail habitat. Trees along the Missouri River sheltered whitetails, but you didn’t have to venture far up feeder streams to the west before the woods dwindled to grass. The famous Platte River, a mile wide and inch deep, was nearly treeless. A few cedars, plum thickets, cottonwoods and other deciduous trees clung to steep banks and damp ravines here and there, especially along the Niobrara River, but millions of grazing bison and ferocious prairie wildfires minimized whitetail habitat in most of the state. Then farmers came. Suddenly Nebraska was a whitetail smorgasbord with corn, wheat, oats, alfalfa and beans, but whitetails remained scarce into the middle of the 20th century due to a shortage of escape cover. But that was coming. Farmers were planting tree claims for firewood, for shelter around farmsteads and as windbreaks in fields. Simultaneously, the reduction in prairie fires enabled natural generation of brush species. Songbirds carried juniper (red cedar) berries from isolated canyon trees to fence lines and pastures across the sandhills. Now cedars are a major weed species choking out millions of acres of formerly productive grasslands. Ponderosa pines, native to the high ridges in northwest Nebraska, similarly advanced in the absence of fire. Rivers in flat, grassland areas like the Elkhorn, Loup, Blue and Republican became lined with deciduous brush. Willows and cattails flourished behind new dams as well as in rainwater basins in south-central counties.

Today Nebraska, while still covered with plenty of grasslands (prairie chickens and sharptailed grouse still thrive here), is also a brushy, whitetail paradise with all the agricultural abundance and productivity of famous Midwest whitetail havens. Landowners and outfitters like Lance Kuck are managing for older bucks, and their efforts are yielding results.

Hunters can approach Nebraska whitetails the same way they hunt Ohio deer, but Westerners incorporate mule-deer hunting tactics, too. While hunting the Platte River Valley near Paxton with Jim Martinosky of Central Nebraska Outfitters, I regularly scanned wide hay fields with a spotting scope. It was the most efficient way to find a good buck. Jim had dozens of stands in and around the riparian brush, but whitetails have so many feeding and bedding options that an impatient hunter like me does better by going to the deer.

One morning Jim and I spotted two good bucks working does along the edge of the river trees. Several does were feeding on fresh cheatgrass around a windmill 400 yards out in a flat, short-grass pasture. There was no way to get past them to the bucks, so we returned in the afternoon to sit in the grass and watch that cheatgrass patch. At 3 p.m. the largest of our bucks strolled from the trees and marched deep into our pasture, but far to the west.

“Where’s he going?” I asked Jim. Toward a band of 10 does, as things turned out. They’d been lying near another windmill about 700 yards from ours all afternoon and we hadn’t seen them.

“How do they do that?” I added.

“I don’t know,” he replied. “The real question is how are we going to get him?”

The answer was “crawl.” While Jim kept tabs on the herd, I belly-crawled 500 yards through grass tall enough to hide my knees, but not much else. When the deer finally noticed me, they couldn’t figure out what I was. A coyote? They pranced closer, and when my laser rangefinder indicated the buck was at 240 yards, I sat up and took him on his final dinner date. The ability to shoot long is a virtue in Nebraska. Despite all the new brush and forests plenty of vast, open grasslands and fields remain, and whitetails forage and even bed in them. Even where riparian brush is thick, whitetails take to the open.

That’s where Justin and I found my first big LWRO buck in 2010. Despite discovering pounded trails, massive rubs and wide scrapes in the river forests, we found no big bucks. Small ones crossed our paths or foraged in bottomland fields. We even rattled in a couple of young bucks, but the old-timers were on the bison prairies associated with irrigated alfalfa fields.

“All these does have got to lure in the big bucks,” Justin said each day as we glassed fields with dozens of animals, including mule deer, coyotes, ducks, geese and grouse. Then we found a massive 4x4 that two of Justin’s earlier hunters had missed.
“I want to tag this buck if we can,” he said. “He’s the biggest 4x4 I’ve seen this year.”

We went prospecting for him about 1.5 miles into the grassland. Deer feeding in the alfalfa were hiking deep into the grass to bed in pockets of plum brush. We sat on a barren hillside and watched a shallow waterway they followed back toward the fields. A dozen, including three good bucks, filed past. Then we rattled a tall, fairly heavy 4x4 inside of 100 yards.

“This one looks like him, but not quite heavy enough,” Justin explained. “Must be his younger brother.”

We let him walk. Not 10 minutes later, Justin spotted the older brother.

“That’s him. Take a look.”

I took a look. “Let’s go get him,” I said.

We tried. We couldn’t. The old buck was feeding in the alfalfa, surrounded by other deer. There was no way to approach him without alarming half the field.

The next morning, in a world rimmed with frost, we drove toward that field in the half-light and spotted a blocky buck with four does in another alfalfa field. It was him. We drove out of sight, approached from behind a shelterbelt, crawled 150 yards through tall grass and settled behind a pile of old farm machinery.

“He’s at 250 yards. Hurry. Get on him. He’s moving off.”

Indeed he was. He wasn’t spooked, but hurrying after a doe that was walking directly away from us. My Model 70 .30-06 was zeroed for 250 yards. I twisted the Bushnell Elite to 8X, held the crosshair on the lower chest and sent the 150-grain Winchester Bonded bullet flying. The buck jumped, trotted and stopped.

“You got him. Watch him fall.”

But he didn’t. Instead he started walking again—without wobbling.

“Better give him another.”

That shot fell low and woke me up; I had 250 yards stuck in my head. The buck had been walking away, and they cover ground deceptively fast.

“What’s the range?” I asked.

Justin’s rangefinder read 287 yards. I held high shoulder and landed the third shot where I should have put the first.
The clean 8-pointer was a spectacular buck, his neck 36 inches around, his G2s stretching 13 inches. We taped his B&C green score at 143 net. And this was only the third-biggest buck we’d seen in four days of hunting.

“Come back next year,” Justin said. “We’ll have more—and bigger.” He wasn’t kidding. Two hours into my 2011 hunt I spotted, stalked and shot a buck that grossed greater than 150. It was one of the smaller ones in Justin’s trail-camera gallery.

Too bad the University of Nebraska isn’t choosing a team mascot today. Go Whitetails! Nebraska rising.


Lehigh Defense Controlled Chaos Ammo Lead
Lehigh Defense Controlled Chaos Ammo Lead

Review: Lehigh Defense Controlled Chaos Ammo

While much of the history of projectiles has been concerned with keeping a bullet together, Lehigh Defense’s Controlled Chaos is designed to do exactly the opposite, and it is extremely effective.

First Look: Hornady 22 ARC

Engineered to use modern, high-BC bullets, the new 22 ARC is designed for optimum performance in the AR-15 platform, but is equally at home in a bolt-action rifle.

First Look: Savage AccuCan Suppressors

Initially available in three multi-caliber options, Savage’s new AccuCan line of suppressors are lightweight, field-serviceable and reduce not only sound, but other disturbances like flash and recoil.

First Look: Remington 2024 Bullet Knife

Remington Ammunition has announced the release of the highly anticipated 2024 edition of their iconic Bullet Knife. This annual tradition has become a favorite among collectors, often hailed as America's most sought-after pocketknife.

Review: Rossi SS Poly Tuffy .410-Bore Shotgun

Over the years, B. Gil Horman has developed an appreciation for the little .410 Bore, single-shot ‘utility guns.' A great up-to-date example of this class is the latest iteration of the Rossi Tuffy single-shot—the SS Poly.

Head to Head: Common vs. Obscure Hunting Cartridges

What is it that makes a cartridge ideal for your hunting scenario? Perhaps it is ammo availability, or the individual connection with a particular cartridge. We take a closer look at the pros and cons of common and obscure loads.


Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.