The Toughest Bird to Kill

by
posted on November 3, 2014
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **

What's the toughest bird to kill? Some would say sea ducks, particularly eiders and scoters, given their thick feathers. Others may point to late-season pheasants, which I've seen absorb shot, shake it off, and fly off no worse for wear. Then there's Canada geese, scaup, and canvasbacks—all tend to act as if immune to being shot.

However, if you ask me, the toughest bird to kill has nothing to do with species. Any bird presenting a going-away shot—as illustrated in the accompanying photo--presents certain challenges.

Namely there is a tendency to hit the bird in the rear-end and, as a buddy is fond of saying, you have to hit the birds "where they eat, not in their feet." Beyond 25-30 yards, it can be difficult to achieve sufficient pellet-penetration to reach the vitals. You might drop the bird, but your dog will likely have a tracking job ahead of it.

The key to clean kills is putting approximately three or more pellets in the front half--or ideally the front third—of the bird. Fortunately, going-away birds often present a better angle to the vitals than may be apparent. Generally the bird will either rise gently during its escape or "tower" into the air before making its getaway. These birds are quite killable. The shot pattern should be positioned just above the rising bird, while a high, going-away shot may be achieved by leading below and forward of the bird (some people shoot the bird at the peak of the tower, but I prefer to let it sort out a direction—just a personal preference). The biggest mistake people make is putting their bead directly on the bird, which causes them to hit the rising bird "where it feets" and to shoot over the high bird.

Occasionally, however, you will encounter a going-away bird that truly offers no angle to the vitals. Ethics and a knowledge of your pattern and loads come into play here. I'll shoot crossing pheasants and tall, passing geese all day long at 40 yards, but I'm much more conservative when it comes to pulling the trigger on going-away birds. I can't stomach wounding them, and the risk is too great.

Latest

LEDE Updated M2 Field
LEDE Updated M2 Field

New for 2026: Upgraded Benelli M2 Field

Used across waterfowl marshes, turkey woods and upland cover, Benelli's M2 pairs dependability with responsive handling—built to perform in demanding environments while remaining light enough for all-day, on-the-move hunting.

First Look: Remington "Don't Tread on Me" Ammo Buckets

In keeping with the celebration of the 250th anniversary of the United States, Remington has announced the release of its ‘Don’t Tread on Me’ ammo buckets.

Traditions Firearms Outfitter G3 Line Now Includes 400 Legend

Traditions Performance Firearms has added another straight-wall hunting cartridge to its Outfitter G3 lineup in 400 Legend.

New for 2026: Millennium Treestands Deadlok Carbon Shooting Stick Tripod

Millennium Treestands has launched the DeadLock Carbon Shooting Stick Tripod. Engineered for stability and versatility, this tripod provides a platform for hunters, shooters and outdoor photographers.

New For 2026: Trijicon AccuPoint 1-8x24 Riflescope

Trijicon has come back to the rugged AccuPoint for 2026, this time with an 8X zoom range, wide field-of-view and all the robust qualities tho make this one ideally suited for Africa's Dangerous Game species.

New for 2026: Remington Ammunition Shotshell and Rimfire Offerings

Remington Ammunition has announced several new shotshell options, plus a new rimfire load for 2026. This includes new options in Royal Flush upland loads as well as an all-new Final Strut lineup of turkey loads.

Interests



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.