SA Objects to Recommended Denial of Preliminary Injunction in Puppy Ban Case

by
posted on February 28, 2025
** When you buy products through the links on our site, we may earn a commission that supports NRA's mission to protect, preserve and defend the Second Amendment. **
Irish Setter Lede

On February 25, the Sportsmen’s Alliance Foundation filed an objection to a magistrate judge’s recommendation to deny SAF’s request for preliminary injunction in its lawsuit against the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s (CDC) puppy ban. A district judge will now take a fresh look at SAF’s arguments that the CDC’s Dog Rule should be halted until the full legal process can play out.

“While we’re disappointed with the magistrate judge’s recommendation to deny our motion for preliminary injunction, we still feel strongly that the recommendation, and CDC’s defenses, miss the mark,” said Michael Jean, litigation counsel for the Sportsmen’s Alliance Foundation. “We’re hopeful the district judge will agree.”

Oral arguments on the preliminary injunction were delivered before a magistrate judge in December 2024. The magistrate judge delivered a report and recommendation to deny the preliminary injunction in early February 2025. That recommendation is passed along to the presiding district judge for a final decision. However, because SAF objected to the recommendation, the district judge will now review the request for preliminary injunction outside of the magistrate judge’s report and recommendation.

SAF’s legal arguments remain sound. CDC exceeded its authority in promulgating the Dog Rule, and precedent from multiple courts, including the Supreme Court, concludes just as much. Additionally, just days before oral arguments, CDC announced a forthcoming notice of proposed rulemaking to potentially change the dog import rule. The notice indicates that CDC is second-guessing its own rule and may propose revisions to the requirements for the importation of dogs. Still, CDC continues to defend its unlawful rulemaking.

“We remain confident that our multiple pleadings not only show that CDC’s Dog Rule is unlawful, but that a preliminary injunction is necessary and proper to stop the harm our members are experiencing as a result,” said Torin Miller, associate litigation counsel for the Sportsmen’s Alliance Foundation. “We’re asking the district judge to see through the government’s smoke and mirrors and see the rule for what it is – an egregious usurpation of authority.”

For more on this case, which affects anyone who hunts behind a dog and dog trainers in particular, visit sportsmensalliance.org.

Latest

W H2026 10 Hardware W3871 TAH 1989Lead
W H2026 10 Hardware W3871 TAH 1989Lead

Hardware Review: Ruger American Rifle Gen. II Prairie

Clearly, Ruger did its due diligence in building this very accurate Gen. II Prairie bolt action. Minute-of-angle (and better) groups, a crisp trigger, good looks and all of this with in-store prices averaging around $650, depending on the caliber. That’s pretty remarkable.

5 Do-All Big Game Bullets

The cartridge debate rages on, but what about one do-all bullet? Is there one projectile best suited for nearly all the big game species?

2026 Archery Gear Roundup

Check out some of the hottest new archery gear of this season.

Montana Sending a Strong Anti-Poaching Message

In the last 30 days Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks (MFWP) has completed a variety of investigations and reported sentences that have followed others. The announcements are a stark reminder to follow every rule, poaching is not hunting and sportsmen are not shy about turning in violators.

Range Review: Ranger Point Precision Enhanced Rossi R95 Trapper

This compact .45-70 Government lever gun from Rossi only gets better with Ranger Point Precision aluminum furniture installed!

#SundayGunday: Henry SPD Predator

Coming out of the skunkworks lab at Henry Repeating Arms is one lever-action series mighty enough to bear Supreme in its nomenclature. And given the fact this is a Special Products Division (SPD) rifle, it’s sure to host a few features otherwise not-so-standard on yesteryear’s lever gun. The SPD Predator is the focal point of this range session. So, let’s take it shooting and run through some details.

Interests



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.