Do Coyotes Kill Mature Deer?

by
posted on December 27, 2011
bs_2015_fs.jpg (23)

Many of my friends in the online hunting community received an email forward recently that shows two scrawny coyotes attacking and killing a mature, healthy-looking whitetail buck. There was also another one of a cougar killing a big buck near a deer feeder. So this led many people to proclaim the opposite of what we usually hear from anti-hunters and armchair biologists: that predators prey on only the weak, old or sick animals. This email seems to lend credibility to disproving the following myth:

The Myth:
Coyotes and other predators only prey on the sick and weak.

The Investigation:
Before we believe an Internet email that was forwarded by dubious sources (the last time I believed one I nearly sent my life savings to help a "friend" in needwho was trapped in Nigeria) we need to ask the experts rather than assume this email is legit. (The deer could be sick, or the photo could be a fake.)

The Expert Deferral:
Larry "Mr. Whitetail" Weishuhn is a degree-holding wildlife biologist, and probably more importantly, has literally spent a lifetime in the outdoors studying whitetails and coyotes in their natural environment. So I asked him if average coyotes can killdeer, including mature bucks.

"Yes, coyotes do kill healthy adult deer! No question about it," said Weishuhn.

For a second opinion, I asked lifelong hunter, trapper, Colorado game warden and outdoor writer photographer/writer Judd Cooney.

He said the same thing. "I have seen it [a coyote killing a mature deer] with my own eyes on many occasions," said Cooney. (He’s got the photos to prove it.)

The Conclusion:
Myth busted. Despite what classroom biologists or anti-hunters with anti-predator-control agendas may tell you, coyotes and other predators such as mountain lions, do routinely kill large, healthy deer.

Latest

33 Winchester Old Box
33 Winchester Old Box

Behind the Bullet: .33 Winchester

Phil Massaro dives into the history and performance of the .33 Winchester.

New for 2025: Springfield Armory Model 2020 Heatseeker

Springfield Armory has announced the Springfield Armory Model 2020 Heatseeker, a compact chassis-based rifle crafted for shooters who demand bolt-action precision and AR-style modularity in one uncompromising, suppressor-ready platform.

Selway Wilderness Outfitters: Your Gateway to the Backcountry

Looking for a new place to chase elk, deer, bear, mountain lion or wolvers, or even do some fishing in the offseason? Want to do it in the heart of Idaho's backcountry, far from towns or even road access? Check out Selway Wilderness Outfitters.

Hardware Review: Taurus Expedition

After a year of testing the Expedition and using it afield, contributor Jeff Johnston believes it’s one of the best compact, hunting/target shooting/utility rifles available for less than $700.

Tested: G9 Defense's Woodsman and EHP Ammunition

These monolithic metal handgun bullets provide an alternative to hollow points for fans of the great outdoors.

NRA Takes Fight to Defend Constitutional Rights of Young Adults to U.S. Supreme Court

SCOTUS petitioned to hear challenge to Florida’s ban on firearm purchases by adults under 21.

Interests



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.