Greatest Field Trial Upset of All Time?

by
posted on March 26, 2014

English setter "Shadow Oak Bo" has made history by besting a field of mostly pointers to win his second straight National Championship Field Trial at Ames Plantation. Why is this a big deal? A setter hasn't won back-to-back nationals in 112 years; in fact, Bo's initial victory was the first win by a setter in 43 years.

Arguably Bo's championship defense is even more impressive than that of a female setter named Sioux, who repeated in 1901-1902. As my buddy Brian Lynn notes, "When she repeated, it was against a field of only 10 other dogs—all of which were setters. Bo squared off against a [75-dog] field overwhelmingly made up of pointers."

Those familiar with the rules of pointing-breed trials will appreciate what a powerful setter is required to defeat the pointers. Are Bo's two championships the greatest field trial upset of all-time?

Only one other comes to mind. In October 2005, English cocker spaniel "Warrener's California Quail" (call name Storm) defeated an 86-dog field of mostly English springer spaniels to win the Canadian National Championship spaniel trial. It's the only time in the event's 47-year history that a cocker spaniel has defeated the springers, which are at a major advantage in terms of size, stamina and strength.

"Some said it would take a miracle for a cocker to defeat a springer in a national," wrote Storm's handler/trainer Paul McGagh. "'Do you believe in miracles?' I asked [owner Vicky Thomas] when I phoned her. Storm had won."

Latest

Wraith Mini 4K Lede
Wraith Mini 4K Lede

#SundayGunday: Sightmark Wraith Mini 4K

On this week's #SundayGunday, Senior Executive Editor Jon Draper checks out the Sightmark Wraith Mini 4K.

Recipe: Kicked-Up Wild Turkey Dip

Wild turkey has incredible flavor and is highly versatile. Consider using it for a tailgate party, watching your favorite sports team or as the ultimate starter in a hunting camp.

Argentina: Where Ignorance is Bliss, and the Dove Hunting is Heavenly

They say that ignorance is bliss, and it is, until that bliss is snatched away by the cold, icy hand of reality. In this case, that hand was wielded by a fellow hunter sitting shotgun in an approaching pickup truck.

4-Play Turkey Calls Debuts Diaphragm Calls

The folks over at 4-Play turkey calls, not content to constrain themselves to their excellent line of box calls, have debuted a line of diaphragm calls that are sure to make toms close that las tidbit of distance.

New for 2025: Rossi R95 TBP Series

Rossi USA has unveiled the next evolution in the R95 family: the R95 TBP (Triple Black Pistol). This new lever-action pistol delivers all the features shooters enjoy about the rugged R95 Triple Black rifle in a compact, maneuverable platform.

Head to Head: 7mm Remington Magnum vs. 7mm STW

We recently ran a battle between the two newest 7mms—7mm PRC vs. 7mm Backcountry. In the comments, we noticed quite a few folks having an entirely different debate about two older stalwarts—7mm Rem. Mag. vs. 7mm STW. Read on to find out which of these classic cartridges comes out on top.

Interests



Get the best of American Hunter delivered to your inbox.